Original Paper

Termination rates after prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome, spina bifida, anencephaly, and Turner and Klinefelter syndromes: a systematic literature review

Caroline Mansfield

Psychology and Genetics Research Group, Guy's, King's and St Thomas' Medical School (King's College), Guy's Campus, London, SE1 9RT, UK.

All authors writing on behalf of a European Concerted Action: DADA (Decision‐making After the Diagnosis of a fetal Abnormality)Search for more papers by this author
Suellen Hopfer

Psychology and Genetics Research Group, Guy's, King's and St Thomas' Medical School (King's College), Guy's Campus, London, SE1 9RT, UK.

Search for more papers by this author
Theresa M. Marteau

Corresponding Author

E-mail address:t.marteau@kcl.ac.uk

Psychology and Genetics Research Group, Guy's, King's and St Thomas' Medical School (King's College), Guy's Campus, London, SE1 9RT, UK.

Psychology and Genetics Research Group, Guy's, King's and St Thomas' Medical School (King's College), Guy's Campus, London, SE1 9RT, UK.
Search for more papers by this author

Abstract

The aims of this systematic literature review are to estimate termination rates after prenatal diagnosis of one of five conditions: Down syndrome, spina bifida, anencephaly, and Turner and Klinefelter syndromes, and to determine the extent to which rates vary across conditions and with year of publication. Papers were included if they reported (i) numbers of prenatally diagnosed conditions that were terminated, (ii) at least five cases diagnosed with one of the five specified conditions, and (iii) were published between 1980 and 1998. 20 papers were found which met the inclusion criteria. Termination rates varied across conditions. They were highest following a prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome (92 per cent; CI: 91 per cent to 93 per cent) and lowest following diagnosis of Klinefelter syndrome (58 per cent; CI: 50 per cent to 66 per cent). Where comparisons could be made, termination rates were similar in the 1990s to those reported in the 1980s. Copyright © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Number of times cited: 119

  • , Prenatal Diagnosis of Down Syndrome, Advances in Research on Down Syndrome, 10.5772/intechopen.71064, (2018).
  • , Perceptions and Discourses Relating to Genetic Testing: Interviews with People with Down Syndrome, Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities, 30, 2, (395-406), (2016).
  • , The Evolution of Spina Bifida Treatment Through a Biomedical Ethics Lens, HEC Forum, 10.1007/s10730-017-9327-2, 29, 3, (197-211), (2017).
  • , Created in the Image of God: Bioethical Implications of the Imago Dei, Christian bioethics: Non-Ecumenical Studies in Medical Morality, 23, 3, (219), (2017).
  • , Down syndrome: from the age of characterization to the era of curative approach, The Nucleus, 10.1007/s13237-016-0187-y, 60, 2, (197-208), (2016).
  • , Introduction, Contemporary Controversies in Catholic Bioethics, 10.1007/978-3-319-55766-3_19, (289-295), (2017).
  • , Clashes of consensus: on the problem of both justifying abortion of fetuses with Down syndrome and rejecting infanticide, Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics, 38, 3, (195), (2017).
  • , The Optimal Cutoff Value of a Diagnostic Test, Medical Decision Making, 10.1007/978-3-662-53432-8_8, (149-172), (2017).
  • , Prenatal screening and prenatal diagnosis: contemporary practices in light of the past, Journal of Medical Ethics, 42, 6, (334), (2016).
  • , Zika Virus and Pregnancy, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 128, 2, (405), (2016).
  • , Estimates of the live births, natural losses, and elective terminations with Down syndrome in the United States, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 167, 4, (756-767), (2015).
  • , The Case of the Missing Hand: Gender, Disability, and Bodily Norms in Selective Termination, Hypatia, 30, 1, (82-96), (2014).
  • , Parental Decisions Following Prenatal Diagnosis of Chromosomal Abnormalities: Implications for Genetic Counseling Practice in Japan, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 10.1007/s10897-014-9744-1, 24, 1, (117-121), (2014).
  • , Support Desired by Women Following Termination of Pregnancy for a Fetal Anomaly, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 24, 6, (952), (2015).
  • , Printing Unrealistic Expectations: A Closer Look at Newspaper Representations of Noninvasive Prenatal Testing, AJOB Empirical Bioethics, 6, 1, (68), (2015).
  • , Late termination of pregnancy for lethal fetal anomalies: a national survey of maternal–fetal medicine specialists, Contraception, 10.1016/j.contraception.2014.10.005, 91, 1, (12-18), (2015).
  • , Healthy citizenship beyond autonomy and discipline: Tactical engagements with genetic testing, BioSocieties, 10, 3, (295), (2015).
  • , Pregnancy outcomes of prenatally diagnosed Turner syndrome: a French multicenter retrospective study including a series of 975 cases, Prenatal Diagnosis, 34, 12, (1133-1138), (2014).
  • , A qualitative exploration of mothers’ and fathers’ experiences of having a child with Klinefelter syndrome and the process of reaching this diagnosis, European Journal of Human Genetics, 10.1038/ejhg.2013.102, 22, 1, (18-24), (2013).
  • , Maternal coping, appraisals and adjustment following diagnosis of fetal anomaly, Prenatal Diagnosis, 33, 12, (1137-1145), (2013).
  • , Mifepristone–Misoprostol Dosing Interval and Effect on Induction Abortion Times, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 121, 6, (1335), (2013).
  • , Generation, Age and the Logic of Correspondence, Master-Servant Childhood, 10.1057/9781137364791_5, (82-106), (2013).
  • , Defectos congénitos en recién nacidos y fetos procedentes de interrupción del embarazo tras diagnóstico prenatal en el período 1982-2009, Medicina Clínica, 141, 4, (152), (2013).
  • , Genetic Analysis in Pregnancy with Fetal Pathologic Ultrasound Findings, Biotechnology & Biotechnological Equipment, 27, 3, (3829), (2013).
  • , The Decision to Continue a Pregnancy Affected by Down Syndrome: Timing of Decision and Satisfaction with Receiving a Prenatal Diagnosis, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 22, 5, (587), (2013).
  • , Variables Influencing Pregnancy Termination Following Prenatal Diagnosis of Fetal Chromosome Abnormalities, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 10.1007/s10897-012-9539-1, 22, 2, (238-248), (2012).
  • , Differences between selective termination of pregnancy and fetal reduction in multiple pregnancy: a narrative review, Reproductive BioMedicine Online, 10.1016/j.rbmo.2013.02.004, 26, 6, (542-554), (2013).
  • , Current Estimate of Down Syndrome Population Prevalence in the United States, The Journal of Pediatrics, 10.1016/j.jpeds.2013.06.013, 163, 4, (1163-1168), (2013).
  • , Parental and professional agency in terminations for fetal anomalies: analysis of Finnish women's accounts, Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research, 15, 1, (33), (2013).
  • , Pregnancy termination following prenatal diagnosis of anencephaly or spina bifida: A systematic review of the literature, Birth Defects Research Part A: Clinical and Molecular Teratology, 94, 11, (857-863), (2012).
  • , “Did you find that out in time?”: New life trajectories of parents who choose to continue a pregnancy where a genetic disorder is diagnosed or likely, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 158A, 2, (373-383), (2011).
  • , Prenatal testing for Down syndrome: The perspectives of parents of individuals with Down syndrome, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 158A, 4, (743-750), (2012).
  • , Prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome: a systematic review of termination rates (1995–2011), Prenatal Diagnosis, 32, 2, (142-153), (2012).
  • , Imagined futures: how experiential knowledge of disability affects parents’ decision making about fetal abnormality, Health Expectations, 15, 2, (139-156), (2011).
  • , Attitudes towards prenatal testing and termination of pregnancy in British Pakistani parents and relatives of children with recessive conditions in the UK, Prenatal Diagnosis, 32, 10, (954-959), (2012).
  • , A comparison of decisions about prenatal diagnosis and pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 30, 4, (377), (2012).
  • , Reproductive decisions after fetal genetic counselling, Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2012.04.001, 26, 5, (517-529), (2012).
  • , Attitudes toward prenatal genetic testing for Treacher Collins syndrome among affected individuals and families, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 158A, 7, (1556), (2012).
  • , Decision Making Following a Prenatal Diagnosis of Down Syndrome: An Integrative Review, Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health, 57, 2, (156-164), (2012).
  • , Decision to abort after a prenatal diagnosis of sex chromosome abnormality: a systematic review of the literature, Genetics in Medicine, 14, 1, (27), (2012).
  • , What's on the Genetics Test?, The American Biology Teacher, 74, 1, (15), (2012).
  • , Outcome of fetuses with Turner syndrome: a 10-year congenital anomaly register based study, The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine, 25, 1, (68), (2012).
  • , Parents' perspectives on the unforeseen finding of a fetal sex chromosomal aneuploidy, Prenatal Diagnosis, 31, 3, (286-292), (2011).
  • , Evaluation of the United States pediatric urology workforce and fellowships: A series of surveys performed in 2006–2010, Journal of Pediatric Urology, 7, 4, (446), (2011).
  • , Patient and provider attitudes toward screening for Down syndrome in a Latin American country where abortion is illegal, International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics, 115, 3, (235-239), (2011).
  • , Risk and reproductive decisions: British Pakistani couples’ responses to genetic counselling, Social Science & Medicine, 73, 1, (111), (2011).
  • , Detectando más-formações, detectando riscos: dilemas do diagnóstico pré-natal, Horizontes Antropológicos, 17, 35, (103), (2011).
  • , Investigation of ultrasound screening efficiency for neural tube defects during pregnancy in rural areas of China, Public Health, 125, 9, (639), (2011).
  • , Age-independent first trimester screening for Down syndrome: analysis of three modified software programs with 6,508 pregnancies, Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 283, 4, (749), (2011).
  • , Efficacy of cognitive behavioral internet-based therapy in parents after the loss of a child during pregnancy: pilot data from a randomized controlled trial, Archives of Women's Mental Health, 14, 6, (465), (2011).
  • , Selective Abortion for Down Syndrome: The Relation Between the Quality of Intergroup Contact, Parenting Expectations, and Willingness to Terminate, Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 40, 3, (554-578), (2010).
  • , Exploring Adoption with Clients: The Need for Adoption Education Within the Genetic Counseling Profession, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 19, 4, (305), (2010).
  • , Parental Decisions Regarding a Prenatally Detected Fetal Chromosomal Abnormality and the Impact of Genetic Counseling: An Analysis of 38 Cases with Aneuploidy in Southeast Turkey, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 19, 3, (241), (2010).
  • , Zespół Klinefeltera: wczesne rozpoznanie szansą na skuteczność terapii zaburzeń rozwojowych, Pediatria Polska, 85, 6, (543), (2010).
  • , Prenatal Testing for Down Syndrome: Comparison of Screening Practices in the UK and USA, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 19, 2, (112), (2010).
  • , Clinical Implications of First-Trimester Screening, Clinics in Laboratory Medicine, 30, 3, (605), (2010).
  • , The ethics of abortions for fetuses with congenital abnormalities, European Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology and Reproductive Biology, 152, 2, (148), (2010).
  • , Termination of pregnancy following prenatal diagnosis in France: how severe are the foetal anomalies?, Prenatal Diagnosis, 30, 6, (531-539), (2010).
  • , Prenatal screening and diagnosis of neural tube defects, Prenatal Diagnosis, 29, 4, (402-411), (2009).
  • , Frecuencia del síndrome de Down en Asturias y tendencia temporal, 1990–2004, Medicina Clínica, 132, 15, (580), (2009).
  • , Recasting Hope: A process of adaptation following fetal anomaly diagnosis, Social Science & Medicine, 68, 3, (462), (2009).
  • , Choosing not to choose: reproductive responses of parents of children with genetic conditions or impairments, Sociology of Health & Illness, 31, 1, (81-97), (2008).
  • , Measurement of Nuchal Translucency and the Prenatal Diagnosis of Down Syndrome, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 114, 4, (829), (2009).
  • , Trends in prenatal sonography use and subsequent urologic diagnoses and abortions in the United States, Journal of Pediatric Urology, 5, 6, (490), (2009).
  • , Psychological impact on women after second and third trimester termination of pregnancy due to fetal anomalies versus women after preterm birth—a 14-month follow up study, Archives of Women's Mental Health, 12, 4, (193), (2009).
  • , Attitudes toward the acceptability of reasons for pregnancy termination due to fetal abnormalities among prenatal care providers and consumers in Israel, Prenatal Diagnosis, 28, 6, (518-524), (2008).
  • , Parental decisions regarding prenatally detected fetal sex chromosomal abnormality and the impact of genetic counselling: An analysis of 57 cases in Taiwan, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 48, 2, (155-159), (2008).
  • , Late-Term Abortion for Fetal Anomaly: Vietnamese Women's Experiences, Reproductive Health Matters, 16, sup31, (46), (2008).
  • , Prenatal detection of trisomy 21 by second‐trimester ultrasound examination and maternal age in a non‐selected population of 49 314 births in Norway, Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology, 32, 4, (493-500), (2008).
  • , Survey of prenatal screening policies in Europe for structural malformations and chromosome anomalies, and their impact on detection and termination rates for neural tube defects and Down’s syndrome, BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 115, 6, (689-696), (2008).
  • , Diagnostic prénatal et prévalence de la trisomie 21 en population parisienne, 2001–2005, Gynécologie Obstétrique & Fertilité, 36, 2, (146), (2008).
  • , The Individualist Model of Autonomy and the Challenge of Disability, Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 5, 2-3, (193), (2008).
  • , Exploring Physicians’ Views and Values in Relation to Maternal Serum Screening, Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada, 30, 7, (564), (2008).
  • , Decisions About Testing and Termination of Pregnancy for Different Fetal Conditions: A Qualitative Study of European White and Pakistani Mothers of Affected Children, Journal of Genetic Counseling, 17, 6, (560), (2008).
  • , Prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal abnormalities in a resource‐poor setting, International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics, 103, 1, (16-21), (2008).
  • , Parental decisions to abort or continue a pregnancy following prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal abnormalities in a setting where termination of pregnancy is not legally available, Prenatal Diagnosis, 27, 3, (228-232), (2006).
  • , Attitudes to prenatal testing and termination of pregnancy for fetal abnormality: a comparison of white and Pakistani women in the UK, Prenatal Diagnosis, 27, 5, (419-430), (2007).
  • , Outcome of chromosomally abnormal pregnancies in Lebanon: obstetricians' roles during and after prenatal diagnosis, Prenatal Diagnosis, 27, 6, (525-534), (2007).
  • , Unexpected Diagnosis of Fetal Abnormality: Women’s Encounters with Caregivers, Birth, 34, 1, (80-88), (2007).
  • , Attributions and Reported Communication of a Diagnosis of Down Syndrome, Health Communication, 22, 2, (115), (2007).
  • , Fetal Diagnosis – Obligations of the Clinician, Fetal Diagnosis and Therapy, 22, 3, (233), (2007).
  • , Pregnancy interrupted: loss of a desired pregnancy after diagnosis of fetal anomaly, Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics & Gynecology, 28, 1, (37), (2007).
  • , Complicated grief after traumatic loss, European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience, 257, 8, (437), (2007).
  • , The Changing Context of Neonatal Decision Making: are the Consumerist and Disability Rights Movements Having an Effect?, Bioethical Issues, Sociological Perspectives, 10.1016/S1057-6290(07)09003-1, (65-84)
  • , Maternal decision to terminate pregnancy in case of Down syndrome, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 196, 2, (149.e1), (2007).
  • , Awareness and attitude toward prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal abnormalities in patients with no access to legal termination of pregnancy, Prenatal Diagnosis, 26, 10, (885-891), (2006).
  • , Variation in the decision to terminate pregnancy in the setting of fetal aneuploidy, Prenatal Diagnosis, 26, 8, (667-671), (2006).
  • , Understandings of Down's syndrome: A Q methodological investigation, Social Science & Medicine, 63, 5, (1188), (2006).
  • , Expectations of the parenting experience and willingness to consider selective termination for Down Syndrome, Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 24, 1, (43), (2006).
  • , Gestational age at abortion: The impact of first-trimester risk assessment for aneuploidy, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 195, 3, (839), (2006).
  • , From a genetic innovation to mass health programmes: The diffusion of Down's Syndrome prenatal screening and diagnostic techniques in France, Social Science & Medicine, 63, 8, (2041), (2006).
  • , Long‐term psychological consequences of pregnancy termination for fetal abnormality: a cross‐sectional study, Prenatal Diagnosis, 25, 3, (253-260), (2005).
  • , Attitudes towards prenatal diagnosis and termination in women who have a sibling with Down's syndrome, Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 23, 2, (181), (2005).
  • , Trauma and grief 2–7 years after termination of pregnancy because of fetal anomalies – a pilot study, Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics & Gynecology, 26, 1, (9), (2005).
  • , Pregnancy interruption after second trimester diagnosis of fetal structural anomalies: The New Jersey Fetal Abnormalities Registry, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 193, 4, (1492), (2005).
  • , Comparison of perinatal grief after dilation and evacuation or labor induction in second trimester terminations for fetal anomalies, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 192, 6, (1928), (2005).
  • , Can Turner syndrome teach us about the pathogenesis of chronic cholestasis?, Hepatology, 40, 5, (1226-1228), (2004).
  • , Turner syndrome: Evaluation of prenatal diagnosis in 19 European registries, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 129A, 1, (16-20), (2004).
  • , Termination of pregnancy: attitudes and behavior of women in a traditional society, Prenatal Diagnosis, 24, 11, (869-875), (2004).
  • , Prenatal diagnosis and management of sex chromosome aneuploidy: a report on 98 cases, Prenatal Diagnosis, 24, 3, (213-218), (2004).
  • , Down syndrome, Turner syndrome, and Klinefelter syndrome: primary care throughout the life span, Primary Care: Clinics in Office Practice, 31, 3, (627), (2004).
  • , Spina bifida, The Lancet, 364, 9448, (1885), (2004).
  • , Factors Influencing Parental Decision Making in Prenatal Diagnosis of Sex Chromosome Aneuploidy, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 104, 1, (94), (2004).
  • , Association between prenatal sonographic findings and post‐natal outcomes in 30 cases of isolated spina bifida aperta, Prenatal Diagnosis, 23, 4, (311-314), (2003).
  • , Trisomy 13 and trisomy 18 in a defined population: epidemiological, genetic and prenatal observations, Prenatal Diagnosis, 23, 10, (856-860), (2003).
  • , Attitudes toward prenatal diagnosis, termination of pregnancy, and reproduction by parents of children with nonsyndromic oral clefts in Argentina, Prenatal Diagnosis, 23, 9, (722-727), (2003).
  • , Coping with termination of pregnancy for fetal abnormality in a supportive environment, Prenatal Diagnosis, 23, 7, (543-548), (2003).
  • , Pregnancy outcome and prenatal diagnosis of sex chromosome abnormalities in Hawaii, 1986–1999, American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A, 119A, 3, (305-310), (2003).
  • , Audit of prenatal and postnatal diagnosis of isolated open spina bifida in three university hospitals in The Netherlands, Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology, 21, 1, (48-52), (2003).
  • , Live and Let Die? Disability in Bioethics, New Review of Bioethics, 1, 1, (145), (2003).
  • , The influence of prenatal screening and termination of pregnancy on perinatal mortality rates, Prenatal Diagnosis, 22, 11, (966-972), (2002).
  • , Outcomes of pregnancies diagnosed with Klinefelter syndrome: the possible influence of health professionals†, Prenatal Diagnosis, 22, 7, (562-566), (2002).
  • , Decision-Making for Termination of Pregnancies With Fetal Anomalies, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 99, 2, (216), (2002).
  • , Living with Marfan syndrome III. Quality of life and reproductive planning, Clinical Genetics, 62, 2, (110-120), (2002).
  • , Nuchal Translucency and the Acceptance of Invasive Prenatal Chromosomal Diagnosis in Women Aged 35 and Older, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 97, 6, (916), (2001).
  • , Pregnancy Outcomes After Prenatal Diagnosis of Aneuploidy, Obstetrics & Gynecology, 97, 5, (729), (2001).
  • , Determinants of parental decisions after the prenatal diagnosis of Down syndrome: Bringing in context, American Journal of Medical Genetics, 93, 5, (410-416), (2000).
  • , Prenatal diagnosis of fetal abnormality: psychological effects on women in low-risk pregnancies, Best Practice & Research Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology, 14, 4, (731), (2000).
  • , Postnatal Identification of Trisomy 21: An Overview of 7,133 Postnatal Trisomy 21 Cases Identified in a Diagnostic Reference Laboratory in China, PLOS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0133151, 10, 7, (e0133151), (2015).